Pizza restaurants

Billy Mac's Pizzeria

4.0 147 reviews Closed 2555 Youngstown Lockport Rd, Ransomville, NY 14131, United States

Discover this place

Billy Mac's Pizzeria stands out as a beloved gem in Ransomville, NY, where pizza aficionados gather for a slice of heaven. Customers rave about the sweet sauce that elevates their classic pizza to new heights, making it a standout choice for pairing with the renowned wings. As Michele Sobczak highlights, the small combo special is perfect for couples, illustrating the restaurant's knack for catering to its patrons' needs.

Notably, Cassy Pettit appreciates the consistent quality and the “magical” bbq sauce that keeps her coming back, solidifying Billy Mac's as a go-to spot even in the most remote of locations. The emphasis on customer satisfaction shines through with Kelly Ryan's account, showcasing their willingness to accommodate requests while delivering mouthwatering flavors.

Whether you're ordering a large spread for an event, like Joanne Vanderheite did with six pizzas and 150 wings, or indulging in their Jeff burger as Tammy Havins did, the experience at Billy Mac’s is always enjoyable. With friendly service and incredible food, a visit to this pizzeria promises a memorable dining experience.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Delivery
Takeout
Dine-in

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Dessert
Table service

Amenities

Restroom

Atmosphere

Casual

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Billy Mac's Pizzeria before visiting.

Reviews for Billy Mac's Pizzeria

4.0

147 reviews

100%

40%

13%

10%

19%

Review highlights

Based on 147 reviews

Billy Mac's Pizzeria consistently receives praise for its high-quality, flavorful pizza and wings, with many customers highlighting the unique sweet sauce and well-crafted BBQ options. Patrons appreciate the generous portion sizes and variety of combo specials, making it a popular choice for both casual meals and larger gatherings. The restaurant's attentive and accommodating service also stands out, particularly in handling special requests and maintaining a welcoming atmosphere. Convenient delivery options and a diverse menu, including standout items beyond pizza, contribute to its strong local following. Overall, Billy Mac's Pizzeria is recognized for delivering reliably delicious food paired with friendly, efficient service in a comfortable setting.

Michele Sobczak

Jun 15, 2025

Best pizza and wings ever!! We love their sweet sauce on the pizza. The small combo special is perfect for my husband and I to share.

Cassy Pettit

Jun 14, 2025

When I moved to the middle of nowhere, I was concerned I would not be able to get good pizza delivered. Then I found this place. And thank God for that! I eat here like every other day. Great pizza, great wings, lunch specials and bbq sauce made of magic!

Kelly Ryan

May 20, 2025

I am picky for my pizza and even more picky about my wings.. the pizza soooooo good. The wing are amazing!!!!! They always listen to my special requestS and make such great food.

Joanne Vanderheite

May 03, 2025

We ordered 6 pizzas and 150 wings and they were all delicious. Service was great and Liz took great care of us. Thank you Billy Macs we will be back again.

Tammy Havins

Apr 28, 2025

We where just in town for a few days but are first night we had a large pizza ut was awesome but even better we went there for lunch and got there Jeff burger at least I think that was the name of but man it was beyond amazing .

Michael Burkitt

Apr 19, 2025

Pizza was delicious and very tasty!!

David Hockenberry

Apr 15, 2025

We have been ordering from Billy Mac’s for years now. We always have a good experience and great food! Tonight we got thin crust pizza with sweet sauce and pepperoni... it was fantastic!

Rachel Held

Mar 26, 2025

This place was known as Little Joe’s when I was a kid. If you love sweet sauce this is the place to go. I make the trip up from Buffalo just for that sweet sweet sauce.